Table.Briefing: China

COP Reality Check + EU Arctic Strategy + Action Cams

  • Climate targets pose huge challenges for China
  • How does the EU assess Beijing’s ambitions in the Arctic?
  • DJI gives GoPro a run for its money
  • EU MEPs visit Taiwan
  • Premier Li calls for relief for small and medium-sized firms
  • Fewer flights to China
  • Financial problems at Byton
  • MeToo accusation against high official
  • Profile: Bettina Schön-Behanzin – expert in Government Affairs
Dear reader,

The heads of state are currently wrestling with the direction of climate policy in Glasgow. As a major polluter, China has to curb its CO2 emissions particularly hard. Within just 30 years, emissions are to be reduced to zero, at least in the overall picture. This poses major economic and social challenges for the People’s Republic. Tens of millions of people are threatened with unemployment. In today’s issue, we are addressing the fundamental question: How can growth, power security, and social stability be successfully balanced?

The effects of the climate crisis are also evident in the Arctic, with rising temperatures and melting ice. And what is bad for the polar bear, pleases riparian countries and the “near-arctic-state”, as China calls itself. New raw material deposits are being uncovered and shorter shipping routes allow for faster ship passages. Amelie Richter analyses how the skirmish over the Arctic could lead to new conflicts and how the EU positions itself.

I hope you enjoy today’s briefing!

Your
Nico Beckert
Image of Nico  Beckert

Feature

China’s climate goals threaten economic and social stability

China’s climate goals are ambitious. Within the next eight years, it wants to reach the peak in national CO2 emissions. By 2060, emissions are then to fall to “net-zero” – at which point only greenhouse gases that are offset elsewhere may be emitted.

The climate targets require action “at an unprecedented speed and scale,” according to climate expert and journalist Liu Hongqiao. “The road to net-zero will not be an easy one.” Economic, social, and political tensions loom. Can China succeed in transforming an economy that causes about 28 percent of global CO2 emissions annually at the necessary pace?

In terms of economic policy, China faces two major challenges: power security and ensuring growth and jobs.

1st challenge: Power security hinges on fossil fuels

China’s electricity mix currently still consists of about 65 percent coal-fired power. It is clear to everyone that it will be difficult to reduce dependence on an energy source that is readily available. For this to happen, the majority of China’s power supply will have to be changed to renewable energies within a fairly short timeframe. In its recently adopted climate plans, the government itself talks about “building before destroying.” Before accelerating the phase-out of coal, sufficient renewable energy capacity, power storage, and transmission capacity should first be built. Those in charge will not take any risks here. The current power crisis made it clear to political leaders what is at stake if the shift to renewables jeopardizes power security.

In the past ten years, China has strongly expanded its renewable energy capacities. Wind energy capacity has increased tenfold. The increase in solar energy has been even steeper. However, the overall power demand also increased heavily. Renewables have not yet been able to push back the share of coal-fired power. And China faces major challenges in building the necessary power lines and storage systems. In recent years, even the construction of some new power plants in the wind- and sun-rich western provinces of Gansu, Xinjiang, and Tibet has been halted due to a lack of required transmission capacity and storage systems. In some provinces, more than seven percent of the power produced from renewable sources is thus lost. In Tibet, the figure is almost 25 percent.

2nd challenge: Growth hinges on fossil fuels

The restructuring of the economy will not be easy either. At present, the majority of China’s economy mainly consists of industry. 38 percent of the economic output originates from the industrial and construction sectors. In economies such as India, Japan, and the USA, the figure is between 20 and 25 percent. In addition, sectors with high power demand and heavy CO2 emissions are dominating: steel, concrete, and aluminum industries, the construction sector, and the (petro)chemical industry. And it is precisely in these sectors that it is most difficult to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

The positive news is that, overall, China has been quite successful in decoupling economic growth from CO2 emissions since 2010. “China has almost doubled per capita economic output since 2010, while CO2 emissions have remained reasonably stable,” says Liu. And yet, the more emissions are supposed to drop, the harder it will be to maintain the old growth model. Growth through the CO2-intensive construction sector has also helped the political elite in crises past. During the most recent economic crisis in the wake of the Covid pandemic, Beijing fell back on old patterns: Billions were pumped into the CO2-intensive construction sector.

However, China’s political leadership is willing to shut down CO2-intensive industries, says Alexander Brown, an analyst at China research institute Merics. This has social consequences: Already since 2015, employment in coal mining and metal production has been on the decline.

The climate reversal also holds potential for major social tensions. The legitimacy of the Chinese Communist Party rests on its ability to create jobs and enable citizens to share in the growing prosperity. There are “threats of social instability and economic stagnation,” writes Sam Geall, an energy and environment expert at think tank Chatham House. This is one reason why the government is not adopting more ambitious climate targets for now.

Where are the new jobs coming from?

China’s CO2-intensive industries employ tens of millions of workers. The construction sector alone employs 54 to over 60 million people, varying by source. Coal mining employs between 2.6 and 5 million Chinese citizens, varying by source. By comparison, according to scientific forecasts, the Chinese solar industry will have created approximately 2.3 million new jobs in manufacturing, assembly, and maintenance by 2035. New solar jobs do not even begin to compensate for lost coal employment

In addition to the loss of jobs in the power industry, millions of workers in the steel, aluminum, and chemical industries, as well as in service industries dependent on these sectors, could lose their jobs. And many of those jobs are located in the poorer regions of the country, says Merics analyst Brown. In Shanxi, coal mining accounts for nearly six percent of employment. “Energy-intensive industries are crucial to driving employment and economic output outside of China’s more developed eastern region,” Brown tells China.Table. The trend is thus hitting rural China the hardest. Yet the government originally wanted to stem the exodus from western China to its rich coastal regions.

What’s more, many workers in the CO2-intensive sectors are poorly educated. According to development economist Scott Rozelle of Stanford University, China is already suffering from a massive shortage of skilled labor. The vast majority of its workforce, according to Rozelle, lacks basic skills to become specialists in the service sector, technicians in a chip factory, or to take on office jobs (China.Table reported). As a result, 200 to 300 million people could be structurally “unemployable” in the future, Rozelle said. In 2008, he was honored with the Chinese Government’s Friendship Award, the highest award for foreign experts.

The International Labour Organization (ILO) also states in a study that the number of new jobs created by the renewable energy sector is limited. The restructuring of the power industry will “increasingly create employment problems”, writes the ILO. Older and poorly trained workers in particular have few employment chances in the sector.

So the faster China rebuilds its economy towards more climate protection, the more of its poorly educated people are at risk of being left behind, which will lead to greater social unrest.

CCP climate protectors are still struggling

On top of all these challenges, China is not a monolithic political bloc. Climate policy is largely defined by the central government. But there are powerful actors in China’s provinces and cities with interests that stand in the way of climate policy. Local officials and municipal leaders traditionally rise within the Chinese Communist Party if they create high economic growth, which in the past has often been at the expense of the environment and the climate.

The preservation of tax revenues and jobs from and in fossil industries is also an important political goal for some provincial governors. There are efforts to give environmental aspects a greater role when promoting civil servants (China.Table reported), but how quickly these efforts will become reality remains to be seen.

Whether China’s political elite will succeed in reconciling climate protection with vital growth, power security and social stability will be a central question in the coming decades. At present, China’s environmental and climate protection lobbies within the political elite “still face an uphill battle to increase domestic ambition when faced with powerful incumbents“, analyses Sam Geall.

  • Climate
  • Coal
  • COP26
  • ILO
  • Renewable energies
  • Sustainability

Brussels watches China in the Arctic

At the end of September, China’s icebreaker “Xuelong 2” returned to its homeport of Shanghai. In its hold, the “Snow Dragon”: The autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV) “Tansuo 4500”, which had been deployed for the first time for scientific research near the seafloor in the latitudes of the Arctic. “Tansuo 4500,” which looks a bit like a giant yellow and red fish, collected important data in the icy waters at the Gakkel Ridge, state news agency Xinhua reported. According to the report, the data will provide information about the exchange of matter and energy and the geological processes in the deep-sea mountain range – and contribute to an “in-depth participation in protecting the environment of the Arctic.”

Because the ice in the Arctic region is melting. “The Arctic is warming three times faster than the global average,” Michael Mann, the EU’s Special Envoy on Arctic Matters, told China.Table. With its climate ambitions as part of the Green Deal, the European Union also has increased interest in the polar region. In mid-October, Brussels published the new edition of its Arctic Strategy. It was prepared jointly by the European External Action Service (EEAS) and the EU Commission. It is primarily about climate and environmental protection, but also about international cooperation.

For example, the EU wants to end the extraction of fossil fuels in the Arctic: “The EU will push for oil, coal, and gas to remain in the ground,” the paper states. Member states are also to be banned from acquiring power from Arctic sources.

China invests in infrastructure and Russian gas

But it’s not just about the environment and the fight against global warming. The melting ice has also roused geopolitical ambitions – not least in China. Among other things, Beijing wants to include the polar routes in its “Belt and Road” initiative and senses raw materials in the region (China.Table reported).

The geopolitical situation in the Arctic has changed a lot recently. There is much more global interest in Arctic affairs,” Mann says. He has been the EU ambassador for the region since April 2020; before moving to Brussels, Mann was the EU ambassador to Iceland for two and a half years. He is therefore well aware of the Chinese influence in the region: China maintains the largest embassy in Reykjavík.

For the EU, Chinese activities in the Arctic region are a safety concern. Beijing’s projects in the Far North are therefore being closely monitored: China is investing in particular in Russian liquefied natural gas, infrastructure projects such as cable connections, and mining, Mann explains. “Beijing is investing a lot, but is not yet as active in the Arctic as it is in other parts of the world.”

EU special envoy skeptical about self-given title ‘arctic-near’

China calls itself a “Near-Arctic-State“. EU Special Envoy Mann finds the self-description “a bit strange.” Everyone can call themselves what they want, he says. However, the concept of a “near-Arctic” state is contrary to China’s geopolitical approaches in its own backyard: There, Beijing is trying to keep actors out of the South China Sea who have, according to China, no business being there, Mann says. The fact that China is now interested in a more distant region is “a bit inconsistent”.

But the Far North has also moved up on Brussels’ agenda. Three EU Member States, as well as two members of the European Economic Area, are arctic coastal states. The EU is also a major consumer of raw materials from the area. And it wants to play a role as a “geopolitical player” in the region, as Mann explains. But since the EU is no military power, it must take the diplomatic route: through regional and international cooperation.

Polar routes remain difficult to navigate

In its revised Arctic strategy, Brussels is also focusing on dialogue with all stakeholders in the region. Mann believes that the potential for conflict in the region is currently low. Russian and Chinese interest in the maritime polar routes is well known. However, these routes are still difficult to navigate, according to Mann. It is therefore rather unlikely that the region will see rampant shipping traffic.

The polar region includes all countries whose territory extends into the Arctic Circle: the USA, Canada, Russia, as well as Denmark for Greenland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden, and Finland. The EU now wants to cooperate even more closely with allies and, for example, expand its diplomatic activities in Greenland. The autonomous territory of Denmark is not part of the EU. A permanent local presence could now help expand Brussels’ influence – and at the same time contain the Chinese one.

China can influence the EU in the north

In addition to the EEAS and the EU Commission, the European Parliament in particular is pushing for a greater commitment in the Arctic. The Chairman of the Committee on Foreign Affairs, David McAllister, stressed: “Given the growing challenges in the Arctic, it is right and important to reassess the common approach to coordinated European action in the High North. In the future, there should be more EU in the Arctic and more Arctic in the EU.”

The region recognized itself as a “zone of peace” until a few years ago. “In recent years, however, the Russian government has been arming itself in the Far North. China is also developing an ever greater strategic interest in the Arctic,” warns CDU European politician McAllister.

China is moving closer to the European states in the north in the polar region. Estonian MEP Riho Terras, a former army general in his home country, sees this as a major risk: “China is being given the opportunity to influence the security of Europe and the whole of the West,” he said during the debate on the EU Arctic strategy. The melting ice has given new momentum to the race for the Arctic.

Against this background, only time will tell whether the Arctic remains free of conflict. The geopolitical race for the North Pole has only just begun.

  • Arctic
  • Climate
  • EU
  • Geopolitics
  • New Silk Road

Battle over the action cam market

The world leader in home camera drones, Shenzhen-based company DJI, unveiled a new action camera on October 27 after more than two years in development. The DJI Action 2 comes in a completely new design. The cube-shaped metal housing looks particularly handy compared to the competition. The current Hero 10 Black from well-known US competitor GoPro is bigger but uses inferior tech. No other Chinese tech product has caused such heated debates in international tech forums since the setback for Huawei smartphones forced by US politics.

The market for waterproof and shockproof sports cameras, which can be clipped to bicycle handlebars, for example, or to a helmet when skydiving, is highly competitive. The segment is benefiting from the digitalization of outdoor sports and the increasing compulsion to share one’s experiences and accomplishments online. The market is expected to grow by almost nine percent annually in the current decade. Global sales of this product group could soon reach three billion euros.

The dominance of the US company GoPro has resulted in a significant segment of the electronics market largely in the hands of American hands. Cameras are long since exclusively offered by Japanese brands, the IBM PC has migrated to Lenovo and other photography now runs in numbers on Korean and Chinese mobile phones. GoPro, on the other hand, has even moved the assembly of its devices out of China in recent years.

Frank Wang rolled up the market for drones

This bastion of the US electronics industry is now under siege. In contrast, Da-Jiang Innovations Science and Technology Co., Ltd, or DJI for short, was founded in 2006 and is one of the great success stories of the Chinese tech industry.

The company’s founder, Frank Wang, would pass for a Chinese hipster in a trendy Berlin café: Chin beard, black rectangular glasses, French cap, and a mocking smile. There’s a reason for his confidence: Wang set a new tech trend in the past decade. Thanks to him, drones went from an expensive professional product to an affordable, easy-to-use mass-produced item. DJI launched its first drone in 2012, and the Chinese company now sells its products in more than 100 countries.

Just three years after founding the company, Wang’s drones were already good enough to fly around Mount Everest. He finally made his breakthrough in 2015 with the now legendary “Phantom 3”, which was developed and manufactured in Shenzhen. The key was that Wang managed to install a camera that produced a live image to a screen on the controls. All that at a price that was hard to beat.

GoPro underestimated its competitor

Until then, “civilian” drones were more a hobby for nerds, who were willing to put a lot of money on the table. In just five years, Wang has conquered the world with his innovations. He now offers drones with VR goggles, which lets users see the world from a bird’s eye view. At times, DJI had a market share of over 70 percent.

The US global market leader GoPro initially underestimated the drone segment and subsequently failed to compete with DJI. In 2017, the company made a loss of $76 million, and in 2018 it still was $24 million. In 2019, Go-Pro pulled out of the drone business, focused on cameras, and rebounded. The company is now profitable again, and its stock price is also up about ten percent already this year, though it’s still about 35 percent below its peak. The fact that DJI is now attacking GoPro in the action camera segment, its core business, seems ominous. To this end, DJI even acquired a majority stake in Swedish camera manufacturer Hasselblad in 2017.

But the group’s global success brought opposition: In the wake of the trade dispute, Washington restricted the use of DJI drones in the US, stating that its cameras and Wi-Fi connections could be used to spy on behalf of China. So far, the evidence is lacking. However, domestic manufacturers have already been able to gain market share in the past year, which was certainly also a goal of US policy.

Meanwhile, DJI’s global market share of the drone market has dropped again to 54 percent. However, the next largest supplier, Autel, only has a market share of seven percent. Autel is a US company that also procures parts of its drones from Shenzhen. The combined global market share of all US manufacturers rose by nine points to 16 percent. In contrast, the overall share of Chinese drones dropped from 77 percent to 64 percent. But that won’t be enough to bring DJI to its knees. And it will be very exciting to see how GoPro and the US government react to DJI’s new action cam. fin

  • Shenzhen
  • Sports
  • Technology

News

EU MEPs in Taiwan

A delegation of MEPs has landed in Taiwan despite warnings from Beijing. The seven EU parliamentarians from the Special Committee on Foreign Interference in all Democratic Processes in the European Union, including Disinformation (INGE) want to learn more in Taiwan about disinformation and cyber-defense, the Taiwanese Foreign Ministry announced. At the same time, an environment for freedom of expression and information will be promoted, it added. On Wednesday, the group met Taiwan’s Premier Su Tseng-chang. A meeting with President Tsai Ing-wen is said to be on the agenda for Thursday.

The delegation was led by French EU politician Raphaël Glucksmann. “Neither the threats nor the sanctions will impress me. Never,” Glucksmann wrote on Twitter on his departure. Glucksmann was struck with sanctions by Beijing in the spring.

The Chinese representation in Brussels had reacted sharply to the trip announcement, insisting on the “one-China principle. “This was the “political basis for the development and expansion of Sino-European relations”, the Chinese representation wrote to the EU on Twitter last week. “We will continue to respond according to developments,” it said. ari

  • EU
  • Geopolitics
  • Taiwan

Li: economy still under pressure

China’s economy “faces new downward pressure,” China’s Premier Li Keqiang said during a visit to the market regulator ministry. The government needs to cut taxes and fees to solve the problems for small and medium-sized businesses, Li said, according to Bloomberg. The premier did not provide details on the causes of the downward pressure or its extent. However, the term is often used by officials to draw attention to slowing growth. According to the report, Li called for companies of all sizes to be treated equally and for greater efforts to fight monopolies and unfair competition.

Beijing’s effort to slow growth in the overheated real estate sector and power shortages from September and early October have hurt the economy (China.Table reported). The harsh Covid measures have also reduced demand in the private sector. In the past, Beijing had used the construction of new housing and infrastructure to boost the economy when growth failed to materialize. Currently, the leadership is looking for a new growth driver. Investment by small firms could provide a “source of healthier, long-lasting growth“, Bloomberg quotes an analyst at financial firm China Renaissance Securities as saying. nib

  • Economy
  • Finance
  • Li Keqiang
  • Taxes

Even fewer flights on China routes

Airlines will have to thin out their services to and from China even further in the coming months. The aviation authority foresees even fewer connections for the winter flight schedule than this summer, which already saw a reduced schedule. This was reported by ARD radio from Shanghai. The reason given for the restriction of flight operations is infection control. In view of the Winter Olympics in Beijing in February, the government is currently trying to preemptively prevent a spread of the delta variant of Sars-CoV-2. (China.Table reported). This includes, according to the government’s understanding, stopping further importations from the outside. That is why China currently has the strictest quarantine rules among major economies.

Meanwhile, business representatives criticize China’s increasing isolation from the outside world as excessive and harmful. The strict entry requirements are a “hardly acceptable hurdle” for German companies, the Chamber of Commerce in Beijing told ARD. “Hopes for a quick opening” are thus off the table, the chamber in Shanghai affirmed. Other Asian countries, unlike China, are currently heading for a cautious opening thanks to rising vaccination rates. fin

  • Air traffic
  • Coronavirus
  • Geopolitics
  • Health
  • Trade

Start-up Byton faces bankruptcy

EV start-up Byton, which was facing troubles for years now, is no longer able to pay wages to its employees. The company is in a serious financial crisis, as business magazine Caixin reports. According to the report, a creditor had filed for bankruptcy proceedings against Byton. A court in Nanjing has also already held an initial hearing.

Byton had unveiled its first vehicle concept, the M-Byte, in 2018 – but the startup ran into trouble afterward. Byton had already begun pre-series production of the M-Byte in October 2019 and was on its way to series production. However, in the wake of the Covid pandemic at the latest, the schedule became uncertain, as promised funds did not flow in the end. Cooperation with Foxconn was seen as a lifeline. As recently as January, Foxconn had announced that it would support Byton in bringing the M-Byte into series production by the first quarter of 2022 – but in July 2020, the company temporarily ceased operations.

Byton was founded in 2016 by former managers of BMW and Nissan and was initially able to raise funds in the high three-digit million range. In total, Byton has burned about €1.1 billion (China.Table reported). nib

  • Autoindustrie

Tennis star accuses high cadre of sexual assault

Tennis player Peng Shuai (35) has accused a senior member of the Chinese Communist Party of sexual harassment. Zhang Gaoli (74) was a member of the Politburo Standing Committee of the CCP from 2012 to 2017. He is one of the most powerful men in the country. The case comes amid a wave of allegations by the MeToo movement about sexual abuse and the exploitation of positions of power. Peng made her accusation public on social media Weibo, according to numerous media outlets on Wednesday. Her accusation was censored shortly after.

Initially, it was a superficial but consensual relationship, Peng wrote. She states that Zhang was party chief in the city of Tianjin at the time. That puts the consensual phase of the relationship between 2007 and 2012. When Zhang held his position in the Politburo Standing Committee, the relationship paused. After he retired from the highest office, however, Zhang resumed contact, Peng recounts on Weibo. He invited her to his home and forced sexual acts on her.

The Weibo post made waves in China. The highest party cadres are usually immune to accusations that do not originate from within the party. But three years ago, MeToo picked up steam in China under the hashtags #我也是 (#WoYeShi) and #米兔 (MiTu). As in Western countries, more and more people are coming forward with reports of assault. Among the accused were Foxconn and Alibaba executives, professors, and Buddhist priests. The leadership has tried in part to contain the movement but has given it free rein elsewhere. fin

  • Chinese Communist Party
  • MeToo
  • Politburo
  • Society
  • Sports

Profile

Bettina Schön-Behanzin – keeping in touch with government agencies

Freudenberg Group Regional Representative for Asia

More than a quarter of a century spent in China, that can change perspectives considerably. “What fascinates me, even when I travel, is the size of the country and its diverse regions. I had the chance to experience the development of China in person for a period of more than 30 years,” says Bettina Schön-Behanzin, Freudenberg Group’s Regional Representative for Asia. She always enjoys traveling to Germany, but when she is back on the plane to Shanghai after her stays in her home country, she is very happy, says Schön-Behanzin.

Freudenberg is a family-owned company based in Weinheim, Germany, and a supplier to automotive, mechanical engineering, textile, and power-generating industries. The company has a strong presence in China, with 28 production sites and almost 8,000 employees. Schön-Behanzin has been overseeing the company’s activities as a regional representative in Shanghai since 2012. “There are two aspects to the role: The internal support for our business units and the external one for the region. This means a lot of government affairs work. We are in contact with the relevant government agencies because we naturally need their support,” she explains.

Schön-Behanzin is also active in other ways in the field of government affairs. For several years, she was Chairman of the Board of the German Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai and is now Vice-President of the European Chamber of Commerce in China. “Both large and small and medium-sized enterprises are represented by the chambers, but the individual assistance mainly serves small and medium-sized enterprises, which simply do not have their own government affairs department,” she says. While the German Chamber of Commerce provides help with market entry, the EU Chamber primarily tries to do lobbying work.

First stay in China cleared all doubts

“The EU Chamber was founded in 2000, with 51 member companies at the time. They said they wanted to give a voice to the industrial sectors of the European Union that are active here in China. So they focused on government relations,” Schön-Behanzin recalls. In working groups tailored to industrial sectors, for example, economic and political recommendations are drawn up for government agencies in China, but also for the EU.

The fact that she would one day end up in China did not come about by chance but was planned. “Since I am very interested in languages and China was a market that had just opened up, I decided to study Chinese,” she recalls. She studied sinology combined with business administration in Bonn and Bochum in the eighties. The first study visit to China cleared any last doubts that she would live there one day. “I was in Shanghai for the first time in 1987 and it was a very decisive year. Because when you start a course like Chinese in Germany, the connection is not quite there. That’s why this year here in China was practically like a confirmation for me.”

Favorite spot: The Bund in Shanghai – with rice fields instead of skyscrapers

She moved to the People’s Republic for good in 1996 and has probably rarely looked back since then. “I think it’s impressive what this country has achieved in such a relatively short time – how modern the whole infrastructure is, if you look at the airports or the roads, and how many people it has actually lifted out of abject poverty into a fairly healthy middle class in that time.”

When asked about her favorite spot in China, Schön-Behanzin says: “That’s the Bund [note: the waterfront promenade in Shanghai opposite Pudong]. When I was a student here, we rode our bikes to the Bund and stood there. I honestly don’t even know what we were actually looking at, because it was rice paddies back then. The TV tower was built in 1988/89. Nevertheless, we were fascinated and looked at the river and the opposite side. When I stand here on the Bund today, it’s quite impressive what all has been built.” Constantin Eckner

  • Trade

Executive Moves

Zhang Yiming has resigned as CEO of ByteDance. Zhang had already announced his retirement at the end of the year in May. He will remain an advisor to the company, but will no longer hold an official position.

Shouzi Chew is stepping down from his position as Chief Financial Officer of ByteDance to devote his time to his role as CEO of TikTok.

Vlado Koljibabic was recently appointed Director of Information Technology and Service Delivery at Daimler Greater China. Previously, he was Head of Cloud Mobility at Mercedes-Benz in Stuttgart.

Dessert

With winter being just around the corner, it’s important to keep your feet warm. This saleswoman advertises socks via livestream from the eastern province of Zhejiang. Whether they also keep warm from afar is not clear.

China.Table Editors

CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

Licenses:
    • Climate targets pose huge challenges for China
    • How does the EU assess Beijing’s ambitions in the Arctic?
    • DJI gives GoPro a run for its money
    • EU MEPs visit Taiwan
    • Premier Li calls for relief for small and medium-sized firms
    • Fewer flights to China
    • Financial problems at Byton
    • MeToo accusation against high official
    • Profile: Bettina Schön-Behanzin – expert in Government Affairs
    Dear reader,

    The heads of state are currently wrestling with the direction of climate policy in Glasgow. As a major polluter, China has to curb its CO2 emissions particularly hard. Within just 30 years, emissions are to be reduced to zero, at least in the overall picture. This poses major economic and social challenges for the People’s Republic. Tens of millions of people are threatened with unemployment. In today’s issue, we are addressing the fundamental question: How can growth, power security, and social stability be successfully balanced?

    The effects of the climate crisis are also evident in the Arctic, with rising temperatures and melting ice. And what is bad for the polar bear, pleases riparian countries and the “near-arctic-state”, as China calls itself. New raw material deposits are being uncovered and shorter shipping routes allow for faster ship passages. Amelie Richter analyses how the skirmish over the Arctic could lead to new conflicts and how the EU positions itself.

    I hope you enjoy today’s briefing!

    Your
    Nico Beckert
    Image of Nico  Beckert

    Feature

    China’s climate goals threaten economic and social stability

    China’s climate goals are ambitious. Within the next eight years, it wants to reach the peak in national CO2 emissions. By 2060, emissions are then to fall to “net-zero” – at which point only greenhouse gases that are offset elsewhere may be emitted.

    The climate targets require action “at an unprecedented speed and scale,” according to climate expert and journalist Liu Hongqiao. “The road to net-zero will not be an easy one.” Economic, social, and political tensions loom. Can China succeed in transforming an economy that causes about 28 percent of global CO2 emissions annually at the necessary pace?

    In terms of economic policy, China faces two major challenges: power security and ensuring growth and jobs.

    1st challenge: Power security hinges on fossil fuels

    China’s electricity mix currently still consists of about 65 percent coal-fired power. It is clear to everyone that it will be difficult to reduce dependence on an energy source that is readily available. For this to happen, the majority of China’s power supply will have to be changed to renewable energies within a fairly short timeframe. In its recently adopted climate plans, the government itself talks about “building before destroying.” Before accelerating the phase-out of coal, sufficient renewable energy capacity, power storage, and transmission capacity should first be built. Those in charge will not take any risks here. The current power crisis made it clear to political leaders what is at stake if the shift to renewables jeopardizes power security.

    In the past ten years, China has strongly expanded its renewable energy capacities. Wind energy capacity has increased tenfold. The increase in solar energy has been even steeper. However, the overall power demand also increased heavily. Renewables have not yet been able to push back the share of coal-fired power. And China faces major challenges in building the necessary power lines and storage systems. In recent years, even the construction of some new power plants in the wind- and sun-rich western provinces of Gansu, Xinjiang, and Tibet has been halted due to a lack of required transmission capacity and storage systems. In some provinces, more than seven percent of the power produced from renewable sources is thus lost. In Tibet, the figure is almost 25 percent.

    2nd challenge: Growth hinges on fossil fuels

    The restructuring of the economy will not be easy either. At present, the majority of China’s economy mainly consists of industry. 38 percent of the economic output originates from the industrial and construction sectors. In economies such as India, Japan, and the USA, the figure is between 20 and 25 percent. In addition, sectors with high power demand and heavy CO2 emissions are dominating: steel, concrete, and aluminum industries, the construction sector, and the (petro)chemical industry. And it is precisely in these sectors that it is most difficult to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

    The positive news is that, overall, China has been quite successful in decoupling economic growth from CO2 emissions since 2010. “China has almost doubled per capita economic output since 2010, while CO2 emissions have remained reasonably stable,” says Liu. And yet, the more emissions are supposed to drop, the harder it will be to maintain the old growth model. Growth through the CO2-intensive construction sector has also helped the political elite in crises past. During the most recent economic crisis in the wake of the Covid pandemic, Beijing fell back on old patterns: Billions were pumped into the CO2-intensive construction sector.

    However, China’s political leadership is willing to shut down CO2-intensive industries, says Alexander Brown, an analyst at China research institute Merics. This has social consequences: Already since 2015, employment in coal mining and metal production has been on the decline.

    The climate reversal also holds potential for major social tensions. The legitimacy of the Chinese Communist Party rests on its ability to create jobs and enable citizens to share in the growing prosperity. There are “threats of social instability and economic stagnation,” writes Sam Geall, an energy and environment expert at think tank Chatham House. This is one reason why the government is not adopting more ambitious climate targets for now.

    Where are the new jobs coming from?

    China’s CO2-intensive industries employ tens of millions of workers. The construction sector alone employs 54 to over 60 million people, varying by source. Coal mining employs between 2.6 and 5 million Chinese citizens, varying by source. By comparison, according to scientific forecasts, the Chinese solar industry will have created approximately 2.3 million new jobs in manufacturing, assembly, and maintenance by 2035. New solar jobs do not even begin to compensate for lost coal employment

    In addition to the loss of jobs in the power industry, millions of workers in the steel, aluminum, and chemical industries, as well as in service industries dependent on these sectors, could lose their jobs. And many of those jobs are located in the poorer regions of the country, says Merics analyst Brown. In Shanxi, coal mining accounts for nearly six percent of employment. “Energy-intensive industries are crucial to driving employment and economic output outside of China’s more developed eastern region,” Brown tells China.Table. The trend is thus hitting rural China the hardest. Yet the government originally wanted to stem the exodus from western China to its rich coastal regions.

    What’s more, many workers in the CO2-intensive sectors are poorly educated. According to development economist Scott Rozelle of Stanford University, China is already suffering from a massive shortage of skilled labor. The vast majority of its workforce, according to Rozelle, lacks basic skills to become specialists in the service sector, technicians in a chip factory, or to take on office jobs (China.Table reported). As a result, 200 to 300 million people could be structurally “unemployable” in the future, Rozelle said. In 2008, he was honored with the Chinese Government’s Friendship Award, the highest award for foreign experts.

    The International Labour Organization (ILO) also states in a study that the number of new jobs created by the renewable energy sector is limited. The restructuring of the power industry will “increasingly create employment problems”, writes the ILO. Older and poorly trained workers in particular have few employment chances in the sector.

    So the faster China rebuilds its economy towards more climate protection, the more of its poorly educated people are at risk of being left behind, which will lead to greater social unrest.

    CCP climate protectors are still struggling

    On top of all these challenges, China is not a monolithic political bloc. Climate policy is largely defined by the central government. But there are powerful actors in China’s provinces and cities with interests that stand in the way of climate policy. Local officials and municipal leaders traditionally rise within the Chinese Communist Party if they create high economic growth, which in the past has often been at the expense of the environment and the climate.

    The preservation of tax revenues and jobs from and in fossil industries is also an important political goal for some provincial governors. There are efforts to give environmental aspects a greater role when promoting civil servants (China.Table reported), but how quickly these efforts will become reality remains to be seen.

    Whether China’s political elite will succeed in reconciling climate protection with vital growth, power security and social stability will be a central question in the coming decades. At present, China’s environmental and climate protection lobbies within the political elite “still face an uphill battle to increase domestic ambition when faced with powerful incumbents“, analyses Sam Geall.

    • Climate
    • Coal
    • COP26
    • ILO
    • Renewable energies
    • Sustainability

    Brussels watches China in the Arctic

    At the end of September, China’s icebreaker “Xuelong 2” returned to its homeport of Shanghai. In its hold, the “Snow Dragon”: The autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV) “Tansuo 4500”, which had been deployed for the first time for scientific research near the seafloor in the latitudes of the Arctic. “Tansuo 4500,” which looks a bit like a giant yellow and red fish, collected important data in the icy waters at the Gakkel Ridge, state news agency Xinhua reported. According to the report, the data will provide information about the exchange of matter and energy and the geological processes in the deep-sea mountain range – and contribute to an “in-depth participation in protecting the environment of the Arctic.”

    Because the ice in the Arctic region is melting. “The Arctic is warming three times faster than the global average,” Michael Mann, the EU’s Special Envoy on Arctic Matters, told China.Table. With its climate ambitions as part of the Green Deal, the European Union also has increased interest in the polar region. In mid-October, Brussels published the new edition of its Arctic Strategy. It was prepared jointly by the European External Action Service (EEAS) and the EU Commission. It is primarily about climate and environmental protection, but also about international cooperation.

    For example, the EU wants to end the extraction of fossil fuels in the Arctic: “The EU will push for oil, coal, and gas to remain in the ground,” the paper states. Member states are also to be banned from acquiring power from Arctic sources.

    China invests in infrastructure and Russian gas

    But it’s not just about the environment and the fight against global warming. The melting ice has also roused geopolitical ambitions – not least in China. Among other things, Beijing wants to include the polar routes in its “Belt and Road” initiative and senses raw materials in the region (China.Table reported).

    The geopolitical situation in the Arctic has changed a lot recently. There is much more global interest in Arctic affairs,” Mann says. He has been the EU ambassador for the region since April 2020; before moving to Brussels, Mann was the EU ambassador to Iceland for two and a half years. He is therefore well aware of the Chinese influence in the region: China maintains the largest embassy in Reykjavík.

    For the EU, Chinese activities in the Arctic region are a safety concern. Beijing’s projects in the Far North are therefore being closely monitored: China is investing in particular in Russian liquefied natural gas, infrastructure projects such as cable connections, and mining, Mann explains. “Beijing is investing a lot, but is not yet as active in the Arctic as it is in other parts of the world.”

    EU special envoy skeptical about self-given title ‘arctic-near’

    China calls itself a “Near-Arctic-State“. EU Special Envoy Mann finds the self-description “a bit strange.” Everyone can call themselves what they want, he says. However, the concept of a “near-Arctic” state is contrary to China’s geopolitical approaches in its own backyard: There, Beijing is trying to keep actors out of the South China Sea who have, according to China, no business being there, Mann says. The fact that China is now interested in a more distant region is “a bit inconsistent”.

    But the Far North has also moved up on Brussels’ agenda. Three EU Member States, as well as two members of the European Economic Area, are arctic coastal states. The EU is also a major consumer of raw materials from the area. And it wants to play a role as a “geopolitical player” in the region, as Mann explains. But since the EU is no military power, it must take the diplomatic route: through regional and international cooperation.

    Polar routes remain difficult to navigate

    In its revised Arctic strategy, Brussels is also focusing on dialogue with all stakeholders in the region. Mann believes that the potential for conflict in the region is currently low. Russian and Chinese interest in the maritime polar routes is well known. However, these routes are still difficult to navigate, according to Mann. It is therefore rather unlikely that the region will see rampant shipping traffic.

    The polar region includes all countries whose territory extends into the Arctic Circle: the USA, Canada, Russia, as well as Denmark for Greenland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden, and Finland. The EU now wants to cooperate even more closely with allies and, for example, expand its diplomatic activities in Greenland. The autonomous territory of Denmark is not part of the EU. A permanent local presence could now help expand Brussels’ influence – and at the same time contain the Chinese one.

    China can influence the EU in the north

    In addition to the EEAS and the EU Commission, the European Parliament in particular is pushing for a greater commitment in the Arctic. The Chairman of the Committee on Foreign Affairs, David McAllister, stressed: “Given the growing challenges in the Arctic, it is right and important to reassess the common approach to coordinated European action in the High North. In the future, there should be more EU in the Arctic and more Arctic in the EU.”

    The region recognized itself as a “zone of peace” until a few years ago. “In recent years, however, the Russian government has been arming itself in the Far North. China is also developing an ever greater strategic interest in the Arctic,” warns CDU European politician McAllister.

    China is moving closer to the European states in the north in the polar region. Estonian MEP Riho Terras, a former army general in his home country, sees this as a major risk: “China is being given the opportunity to influence the security of Europe and the whole of the West,” he said during the debate on the EU Arctic strategy. The melting ice has given new momentum to the race for the Arctic.

    Against this background, only time will tell whether the Arctic remains free of conflict. The geopolitical race for the North Pole has only just begun.

    • Arctic
    • Climate
    • EU
    • Geopolitics
    • New Silk Road

    Battle over the action cam market

    The world leader in home camera drones, Shenzhen-based company DJI, unveiled a new action camera on October 27 after more than two years in development. The DJI Action 2 comes in a completely new design. The cube-shaped metal housing looks particularly handy compared to the competition. The current Hero 10 Black from well-known US competitor GoPro is bigger but uses inferior tech. No other Chinese tech product has caused such heated debates in international tech forums since the setback for Huawei smartphones forced by US politics.

    The market for waterproof and shockproof sports cameras, which can be clipped to bicycle handlebars, for example, or to a helmet when skydiving, is highly competitive. The segment is benefiting from the digitalization of outdoor sports and the increasing compulsion to share one’s experiences and accomplishments online. The market is expected to grow by almost nine percent annually in the current decade. Global sales of this product group could soon reach three billion euros.

    The dominance of the US company GoPro has resulted in a significant segment of the electronics market largely in the hands of American hands. Cameras are long since exclusively offered by Japanese brands, the IBM PC has migrated to Lenovo and other photography now runs in numbers on Korean and Chinese mobile phones. GoPro, on the other hand, has even moved the assembly of its devices out of China in recent years.

    Frank Wang rolled up the market for drones

    This bastion of the US electronics industry is now under siege. In contrast, Da-Jiang Innovations Science and Technology Co., Ltd, or DJI for short, was founded in 2006 and is one of the great success stories of the Chinese tech industry.

    The company’s founder, Frank Wang, would pass for a Chinese hipster in a trendy Berlin café: Chin beard, black rectangular glasses, French cap, and a mocking smile. There’s a reason for his confidence: Wang set a new tech trend in the past decade. Thanks to him, drones went from an expensive professional product to an affordable, easy-to-use mass-produced item. DJI launched its first drone in 2012, and the Chinese company now sells its products in more than 100 countries.

    Just three years after founding the company, Wang’s drones were already good enough to fly around Mount Everest. He finally made his breakthrough in 2015 with the now legendary “Phantom 3”, which was developed and manufactured in Shenzhen. The key was that Wang managed to install a camera that produced a live image to a screen on the controls. All that at a price that was hard to beat.

    GoPro underestimated its competitor

    Until then, “civilian” drones were more a hobby for nerds, who were willing to put a lot of money on the table. In just five years, Wang has conquered the world with his innovations. He now offers drones with VR goggles, which lets users see the world from a bird’s eye view. At times, DJI had a market share of over 70 percent.

    The US global market leader GoPro initially underestimated the drone segment and subsequently failed to compete with DJI. In 2017, the company made a loss of $76 million, and in 2018 it still was $24 million. In 2019, Go-Pro pulled out of the drone business, focused on cameras, and rebounded. The company is now profitable again, and its stock price is also up about ten percent already this year, though it’s still about 35 percent below its peak. The fact that DJI is now attacking GoPro in the action camera segment, its core business, seems ominous. To this end, DJI even acquired a majority stake in Swedish camera manufacturer Hasselblad in 2017.

    But the group’s global success brought opposition: In the wake of the trade dispute, Washington restricted the use of DJI drones in the US, stating that its cameras and Wi-Fi connections could be used to spy on behalf of China. So far, the evidence is lacking. However, domestic manufacturers have already been able to gain market share in the past year, which was certainly also a goal of US policy.

    Meanwhile, DJI’s global market share of the drone market has dropped again to 54 percent. However, the next largest supplier, Autel, only has a market share of seven percent. Autel is a US company that also procures parts of its drones from Shenzhen. The combined global market share of all US manufacturers rose by nine points to 16 percent. In contrast, the overall share of Chinese drones dropped from 77 percent to 64 percent. But that won’t be enough to bring DJI to its knees. And it will be very exciting to see how GoPro and the US government react to DJI’s new action cam. fin

    • Shenzhen
    • Sports
    • Technology

    News

    EU MEPs in Taiwan

    A delegation of MEPs has landed in Taiwan despite warnings from Beijing. The seven EU parliamentarians from the Special Committee on Foreign Interference in all Democratic Processes in the European Union, including Disinformation (INGE) want to learn more in Taiwan about disinformation and cyber-defense, the Taiwanese Foreign Ministry announced. At the same time, an environment for freedom of expression and information will be promoted, it added. On Wednesday, the group met Taiwan’s Premier Su Tseng-chang. A meeting with President Tsai Ing-wen is said to be on the agenda for Thursday.

    The delegation was led by French EU politician Raphaël Glucksmann. “Neither the threats nor the sanctions will impress me. Never,” Glucksmann wrote on Twitter on his departure. Glucksmann was struck with sanctions by Beijing in the spring.

    The Chinese representation in Brussels had reacted sharply to the trip announcement, insisting on the “one-China principle. “This was the “political basis for the development and expansion of Sino-European relations”, the Chinese representation wrote to the EU on Twitter last week. “We will continue to respond according to developments,” it said. ari

    • EU
    • Geopolitics
    • Taiwan

    Li: economy still under pressure

    China’s economy “faces new downward pressure,” China’s Premier Li Keqiang said during a visit to the market regulator ministry. The government needs to cut taxes and fees to solve the problems for small and medium-sized businesses, Li said, according to Bloomberg. The premier did not provide details on the causes of the downward pressure or its extent. However, the term is often used by officials to draw attention to slowing growth. According to the report, Li called for companies of all sizes to be treated equally and for greater efforts to fight monopolies and unfair competition.

    Beijing’s effort to slow growth in the overheated real estate sector and power shortages from September and early October have hurt the economy (China.Table reported). The harsh Covid measures have also reduced demand in the private sector. In the past, Beijing had used the construction of new housing and infrastructure to boost the economy when growth failed to materialize. Currently, the leadership is looking for a new growth driver. Investment by small firms could provide a “source of healthier, long-lasting growth“, Bloomberg quotes an analyst at financial firm China Renaissance Securities as saying. nib

    • Economy
    • Finance
    • Li Keqiang
    • Taxes

    Even fewer flights on China routes

    Airlines will have to thin out their services to and from China even further in the coming months. The aviation authority foresees even fewer connections for the winter flight schedule than this summer, which already saw a reduced schedule. This was reported by ARD radio from Shanghai. The reason given for the restriction of flight operations is infection control. In view of the Winter Olympics in Beijing in February, the government is currently trying to preemptively prevent a spread of the delta variant of Sars-CoV-2. (China.Table reported). This includes, according to the government’s understanding, stopping further importations from the outside. That is why China currently has the strictest quarantine rules among major economies.

    Meanwhile, business representatives criticize China’s increasing isolation from the outside world as excessive and harmful. The strict entry requirements are a “hardly acceptable hurdle” for German companies, the Chamber of Commerce in Beijing told ARD. “Hopes for a quick opening” are thus off the table, the chamber in Shanghai affirmed. Other Asian countries, unlike China, are currently heading for a cautious opening thanks to rising vaccination rates. fin

    • Air traffic
    • Coronavirus
    • Geopolitics
    • Health
    • Trade

    Start-up Byton faces bankruptcy

    EV start-up Byton, which was facing troubles for years now, is no longer able to pay wages to its employees. The company is in a serious financial crisis, as business magazine Caixin reports. According to the report, a creditor had filed for bankruptcy proceedings against Byton. A court in Nanjing has also already held an initial hearing.

    Byton had unveiled its first vehicle concept, the M-Byte, in 2018 – but the startup ran into trouble afterward. Byton had already begun pre-series production of the M-Byte in October 2019 and was on its way to series production. However, in the wake of the Covid pandemic at the latest, the schedule became uncertain, as promised funds did not flow in the end. Cooperation with Foxconn was seen as a lifeline. As recently as January, Foxconn had announced that it would support Byton in bringing the M-Byte into series production by the first quarter of 2022 – but in July 2020, the company temporarily ceased operations.

    Byton was founded in 2016 by former managers of BMW and Nissan and was initially able to raise funds in the high three-digit million range. In total, Byton has burned about €1.1 billion (China.Table reported). nib

    • Autoindustrie

    Tennis star accuses high cadre of sexual assault

    Tennis player Peng Shuai (35) has accused a senior member of the Chinese Communist Party of sexual harassment. Zhang Gaoli (74) was a member of the Politburo Standing Committee of the CCP from 2012 to 2017. He is one of the most powerful men in the country. The case comes amid a wave of allegations by the MeToo movement about sexual abuse and the exploitation of positions of power. Peng made her accusation public on social media Weibo, according to numerous media outlets on Wednesday. Her accusation was censored shortly after.

    Initially, it was a superficial but consensual relationship, Peng wrote. She states that Zhang was party chief in the city of Tianjin at the time. That puts the consensual phase of the relationship between 2007 and 2012. When Zhang held his position in the Politburo Standing Committee, the relationship paused. After he retired from the highest office, however, Zhang resumed contact, Peng recounts on Weibo. He invited her to his home and forced sexual acts on her.

    The Weibo post made waves in China. The highest party cadres are usually immune to accusations that do not originate from within the party. But three years ago, MeToo picked up steam in China under the hashtags #我也是 (#WoYeShi) and #米兔 (MiTu). As in Western countries, more and more people are coming forward with reports of assault. Among the accused were Foxconn and Alibaba executives, professors, and Buddhist priests. The leadership has tried in part to contain the movement but has given it free rein elsewhere. fin

    • Chinese Communist Party
    • MeToo
    • Politburo
    • Society
    • Sports

    Profile

    Bettina Schön-Behanzin – keeping in touch with government agencies

    Freudenberg Group Regional Representative for Asia

    More than a quarter of a century spent in China, that can change perspectives considerably. “What fascinates me, even when I travel, is the size of the country and its diverse regions. I had the chance to experience the development of China in person for a period of more than 30 years,” says Bettina Schön-Behanzin, Freudenberg Group’s Regional Representative for Asia. She always enjoys traveling to Germany, but when she is back on the plane to Shanghai after her stays in her home country, she is very happy, says Schön-Behanzin.

    Freudenberg is a family-owned company based in Weinheim, Germany, and a supplier to automotive, mechanical engineering, textile, and power-generating industries. The company has a strong presence in China, with 28 production sites and almost 8,000 employees. Schön-Behanzin has been overseeing the company’s activities as a regional representative in Shanghai since 2012. “There are two aspects to the role: The internal support for our business units and the external one for the region. This means a lot of government affairs work. We are in contact with the relevant government agencies because we naturally need their support,” she explains.

    Schön-Behanzin is also active in other ways in the field of government affairs. For several years, she was Chairman of the Board of the German Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai and is now Vice-President of the European Chamber of Commerce in China. “Both large and small and medium-sized enterprises are represented by the chambers, but the individual assistance mainly serves small and medium-sized enterprises, which simply do not have their own government affairs department,” she says. While the German Chamber of Commerce provides help with market entry, the EU Chamber primarily tries to do lobbying work.

    First stay in China cleared all doubts

    “The EU Chamber was founded in 2000, with 51 member companies at the time. They said they wanted to give a voice to the industrial sectors of the European Union that are active here in China. So they focused on government relations,” Schön-Behanzin recalls. In working groups tailored to industrial sectors, for example, economic and political recommendations are drawn up for government agencies in China, but also for the EU.

    The fact that she would one day end up in China did not come about by chance but was planned. “Since I am very interested in languages and China was a market that had just opened up, I decided to study Chinese,” she recalls. She studied sinology combined with business administration in Bonn and Bochum in the eighties. The first study visit to China cleared any last doubts that she would live there one day. “I was in Shanghai for the first time in 1987 and it was a very decisive year. Because when you start a course like Chinese in Germany, the connection is not quite there. That’s why this year here in China was practically like a confirmation for me.”

    Favorite spot: The Bund in Shanghai – with rice fields instead of skyscrapers

    She moved to the People’s Republic for good in 1996 and has probably rarely looked back since then. “I think it’s impressive what this country has achieved in such a relatively short time – how modern the whole infrastructure is, if you look at the airports or the roads, and how many people it has actually lifted out of abject poverty into a fairly healthy middle class in that time.”

    When asked about her favorite spot in China, Schön-Behanzin says: “That’s the Bund [note: the waterfront promenade in Shanghai opposite Pudong]. When I was a student here, we rode our bikes to the Bund and stood there. I honestly don’t even know what we were actually looking at, because it was rice paddies back then. The TV tower was built in 1988/89. Nevertheless, we were fascinated and looked at the river and the opposite side. When I stand here on the Bund today, it’s quite impressive what all has been built.” Constantin Eckner

    • Trade

    Executive Moves

    Zhang Yiming has resigned as CEO of ByteDance. Zhang had already announced his retirement at the end of the year in May. He will remain an advisor to the company, but will no longer hold an official position.

    Shouzi Chew is stepping down from his position as Chief Financial Officer of ByteDance to devote his time to his role as CEO of TikTok.

    Vlado Koljibabic was recently appointed Director of Information Technology and Service Delivery at Daimler Greater China. Previously, he was Head of Cloud Mobility at Mercedes-Benz in Stuttgart.

    Dessert

    With winter being just around the corner, it’s important to keep your feet warm. This saleswoman advertises socks via livestream from the eastern province of Zhejiang. Whether they also keep warm from afar is not clear.

    China.Table Editors

    CHINA.TABLE EDITORIAL OFFICE

    Licenses:

      Sign up now and continue reading immediately

      No credit card details required. No automatic renewal.

      Sie haben bereits das Table.Briefing Abonnement?

      Anmelden und weiterlesen